The Colorado Amish—part 1

Colorado Amish country

During Thanksgiving week, my husband and I drove to Colorado to research the Amish communities there before I begin work on the eighth book in my Whinburg Township Amish series, The Highest Mountain. What an experience! Between the magnificence of the landscape and the warmth and humor of the Amish folks themselves, I came away more eager than ever to immerse myself in that world.


So, heading north on Highway 285, we arrived first in the tiny community of Manassa. Since not much is on the Internet about the Colorado Amish except for some excellent articles in the Denver Post (“Amish settle in Colorado’s San Luis Valley, diversifying to support families,” by Ann Schrader is a good one), we felt like detectives looking for clues. And suddenly, there was our first clue—a buggy sign!
Buggy sign in Manassa, CO
While Manassa may be a little depressed economically, you wouldn’t know it by the neat yards and roomy houses of the Amish folks, which are built by hand and, of course, have no electricity running to them.


Our next stop was nearly 100 miles north, in the town of Westcliffe in the Wet Mountain Valley. The approach to town is awe-inspiring, with the Sangre de Christo mountains leaping out of the plains like the shout of an archangel.

The first Amish-owned business we came to was Yoder’s Mountain View Furniture, and we had a delightful conversation with the affable co-owner, Joel Troyer. Once he and my husband got started on hunting—looking at pictures on the business computer of the elk, deer, and antelope Joel had bagged to feed his family—it was all I could do to get a word in edgewise!

I did learn, however, that the differences in soils and farmland from the home communities in Iowa, Kentucky, Ohio, and Lancaster County don’t allow them to plant the same crops, so the Amish in the Wet Mountain Valley have diversified into services:

  • A USDA-approved slaughterhouse
  • A family-run bakery
  • The furniture showroom
  • A sawmill
  • And others

Yodel's Mountain View Furniture, Westcliffe, CO. Photo by Adina Senft.All the furniture at Yoder’s is either made onsite or back in the home communities by family members and friends, and they ship anywhere in the country. The Amish here are very environmentally aware. Case in point: All the outdoor furniture sold at the showroom is made from recycled milk jugs!

2024 Update:

The furniture store has now changed hands and is owned by Merle Yoder, who hails from Holmes County, Ohio. It’s now known as Yoder’s Home Furnishings, and you can browse online here.

There are two church districts in Westcliffe—one in the south and one in the north near the town of Hillside. The Hillside folks came from New York State, Joel told me, and when I asked if one bishop oversaw both churches, as is common, he shook his head. Apparently the Ordnung is too different between the churches, so there is one bishop in each community. When I commented that it looked like the buggies were from the home communities, with the angled bottom of Iowa and Holmes County in a couple of cases and the “Noah’s ark” shape in others, and didn’t have a Colorado “look” to them, Joel nodded in agreement. Apparently folks just drive whatever buggy they arrived in when they moved here. Since there is no buggy maker yet to produce a model just for the communities in Colorado, in sensible Amish fashion, they use what they have.

I’ll post part 2 in a couple of days. This feature is running over at Amish Wisdom with a giveaway, so if you don’t want to wait, you might hop over there!

My latest release is The Longest Roadbook seven in the Whinburg Township Amish series, available at your favorite online retailer. Watch for the next book, The Highest Mountain, featuring the Colorado Amish in summer 2017.

9 thoughts on “The Colorado Amish—part 1”

  1. Linda IngleLinda Ingle

    I would like to stay with the Amish in Colorado for a short time. Is there anything available that would satisfy that?

  2. Stan SmithStan Smith

    I’m from Louisiana, but had a mountain home in the mountains out of Antonito, Co. While spending summers in Colorado, I became fast friends with several Amish families. I’ve visited in their homes, attended their son’s wedding, and they have hired folks to bring them to my home in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. We have since sold my summer home in Colorado as the altitude started bothering me, but continue our friendship via phone. We receive Christmas cards from them, and plan to visit soon. Wonderful, caring, and loving folks. My wife and I have been invited to stay with them in their home when we go back for our visit.

  3. Daniel FergusonDaniel Ferguson

    I want to become Amish

  4. KarinKarin

    How could I get in touch with Amish woman and connect to their circle?

  5. Amy ToussaintAmy Toussaint

    I am a middle school teacher and I would love to take my class to tour the Amish community. We are currently reading “The Giver” and I think an opportunity to see how this community lives would certainly solidify their understanding of dystopia and utopia. Do you have a direct point of contact you could share or any suggestions for experiential opportunities to enhance my student’s understanding of these topics?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *